/ GAMES / Pony Island / Similar Games
/ Search Database Or Try Advanced Search
Our experts have spent time searching for great games similar to Pony Island and have found the following:
Pony Island is an adventure game where you are trapped in a computer by the Devil. You need to crash the computer to escape and stumble upon the Pony Island game that appears unstable. As you hack away at the game you uncover its corrupted code and your task is to access Pony Island's internal programming and save your (and others) souls.
Unfortunately, Pony Island is not available on Android, PS4, PS5, Switch, Xbox One, Xbox X|S or iOS. However, we recommend the following games that offer a similar experience or theme:
Release Date: 04/01/2016
Out Now: Mac and PC
Players: 1
Genres: Brain Game, Narrative (Platform, Point-and-Click and Puzzle)
Accessibility: 0 features documented (Tweet Developer )
Components: 2D Side-On
Developer: D Mullins Games (@DMullinsGames)
Costs: Purchase cost
Here are our hand-picked short list of similar games; the perfect thing to play next if you enjoyed Pony Island. We don't use automatic matching, instead, we hand-pick games that are good to play if you have enjoyed Pony Island.
Year Walk is a horror narrative traversal game where you partake in the ancient Nordic tradition of Year Walking to see glimpses of the future.
Year Walk is a horror narrative traversal game where you partake in the ancient Nordic tradition of Year Walking to see glimpses of the future. As you travel the snowy landscapes by moonlight, you see creatures and characters from Swedish mythology and must solve puzzles to progress.
Out Now: Mac, PC, Wii U and iOS
Oxenfree II: Lost Signals is an unsettling narrative adventure and sequel to Oxenfree.
Oxenfree II: Lost Signals is an unsettling narrative adventure and sequel to Oxenfree. Like that game, you guide your character through choices that affect the direction of the well-written and complex story and tune your radio to overhear mysterious conversations.
Out Now: Android, Mac, PC, PS4, PS5, Switch and iOS
Lorelei And The Laser Eyes is a narrative brain game where you are stuck in a mysterious maze unsure of whether to trust your senses or the people you meet.
Lorelei And The Laser Eyes is a narrative brain game where you are stuck in a mysterious maze unsure of whether to trust your senses or the people you meet. Play involves using the clues you find to solve puzzles and traverse the maze to safety.
Out Now: PC and Switch
MyHouse.Wad is a horror adventure created in the form of a new map for the classic Doom video game.
MyHouse.Wad is a horror adventure created in the form of a new map for the classic Doom video game. It uses the Doom game engine but subverts it to create an unsettling and intriguing experience.
Out Now: PC
Omori is a role-play narrative game about a troubled teenage boy and his dream world alter-ego Omori.
Omori is a role-play narrative game about a troubled teenage boy and his dream world alter-ego Omori. You play as a group of friends explore both the real and surreal world to help both Sunny and Omori deal with (or suppress) fears and secrets.
Out Now: Mac, PC, PS4, Switch and Xbox One
Pony Island 2: Panda Circus is a surreal puzzle game where you play a character hacking a computer.
Pony Island 2: Panda Circus is a surreal puzzle game where you play a character hacking a computer. A sequel to Pony Island, it contains the same hacking, experimentation, and self-reflection, but adds novel mechanics such as archery, conveyor puzzles, and countless other unusual ideas.
Coming Soon: PC
Here are our hand-picked long list of similar games; the perfect thing to play next if you enjoyed Pony Island. We don't use automatic matching, instead, we hand-pick games that are good to play if you have enjoyed Pony Island.
The Gardens Between is a puzzle game set in dreamlike island gardens where you play as best friends Arina and Frendt.
The Gardens Between is a puzzle game set in dreamlike island gardens where you play as best friends Arina and Frendt. You work around the island levels collecting balls of light in your lantern, manipulating time to solve puzzles and remove obstacles.
Out Now: Android, Mac, PC, PS4, Switch, Xbox One and iOS
Baba is You requires some lateral thinking.
Baba is You requires some lateral thinking. Each level is controlled by rules written on the screen, such as ‘Lava is Hot’, ‘Wall is Stop’ and ‘Flag is Move’.
Out Now: Mac, PC and Switch
Toodee and Topdee is a platform puzzle game where you control two characters to complete single-screen levels.
Toodee and Topdee is a platform puzzle game where you control two characters to complete single-screen levels. The twist is that each character exists in a different plane.
Out Now: PC, PS4, PS5, Switch, Xbox One and Xbox X|S
The Rise of the Golden Idol is a point-and-click murder mystery set in the 1970s.
The Rise of the Golden Idol is a point-and-click murder mystery set in the 1970s. A sequel to The Case of the Golden Idol, you investigate different crime scenes, search for clues, question suspects, and make informed accusations to reveal an overarching story linking all the murders together.
Coming Soon: PC, PS4, PS5, Switch, Xbox One and Xbox X|S
Portal is a puzzle game where you manipulate the world around you to move through increasingly complex chambers.
Portal is a puzzle game where you manipulate the world around you to move through increasingly complex chambers. By creating two connected portals- if you walk into one, you walk out the other- you must move yourself around the rooms to escape.
Out Now: Android, Mac, PC, Switch and Xbox 360
Inscryption starts as a card-based adventure where you build a deck of cards to take on adventures and battles.
Inscryption starts as a card-based adventure where you build a deck of cards to take on adventures and battles. To this, it adds escape-room-style puzzles, both in the card game and in the room in which you are playing.
Out Now: Mac, PC, PS4, PS5 and Switch
There Is No Game is a comedic adventure with a strange twist.
There Is No Game is a comedic adventure with a strange twist. From the outset, the game’s narrator insists that there is no game to play.
Out Now: Android, Mac, PC, Switch and iOS
Framed is a puzzle adventure where you rearrange panels of an animated comic book to change the outcome and timeline of the story.
Framed is a puzzle adventure where you rearrange panels of an animated comic book to change the outcome and timeline of the story. With a noir-detective look, the puzzles start simply but soon get complex.
Out Now: Android, PC, Switch and iOS
Five Nights at Freddy's: Security Breach is a survival-horror game where you explore a vast pizzeria and shopping centre while hunted by a murderer.
Five Nights at Freddy's: Security Breach is a survival-horror game where you explore a vast pizzeria and shopping centre while hunted by a murderer. In addition to continuing the intricate and multi-layered story of the previous games, this is the first time you can freely explore the ever-changing world, play mini-games, solve puzzles and fight bosses.
Five Nights at Freddy's (FNaF) is a series of puzzle horror games with jump scares rather than blood and gore.
Five Nights at Freddy's (FNaF) is a series of puzzle horror games with jump scares rather than blood and gore. You play the night-guard at Freddy Fazbear's Pizza and have to survive the night while in your office, checking the cameras and closing the doors, or make repairs, all while being hunted by killer robot animatronics.
Out Now: Android, PC, PS4, PS5, Switch, Xbox One and iOS
Choo-Choo Charles is a survival shooting game that imagines Thomas the Tank Engine in a horror setting.
Choo-Choo Charles is a survival shooting game that imagines Thomas the Tank Engine in a horror setting. You explore an island in an old upgradable train and hunt down Charles the evil spider train.
Donut County offers a simple style of play.
Donut County offers a simple style of play. You drag a hole around the screen; the more things you can make fall in, the bigger the hole gets.
Device 6 is a narrative puzzle where you piece together a mystery through unusual interactions with your device.
Device 6 is a narrative puzzle where you piece together a mystery through unusual interactions with your device. As the story unfolds, you rotate your screen, hold it up to a mirror to read backwards text, and generally search for clues in unusual ways.
Out Now: iOS
A Dark Room is an adventure where you try and survive in the wild.
A Dark Room is an adventure where you try and survive in the wild. The world is depicted with just text but leads you into a dense narrative with intriguing visitors and a steadily expanding world.
Out Now: Switch, Web and iOS
Samsara Room is an abstract point-and-click puzzle-horror game.
Samsara Room is an abstract point-and-click puzzle-horror game. By solving the puzzles hidden throughout the room, you uncover an uneasy story about judgement and atonement told through the things you find.
Out Now: Android, Mac, PC and iOS
Rusty Lake: Roots is an unusual point-and-click puzzle-horror game that has you piecing together your family tree.
Rusty Lake: Roots is an unusual point-and-click puzzle-horror game that has you piecing together your family tree. With a wide range unusual puzzles and game mechanics, like growing a literal family tree, it tells a story of a broken family and dark secrets and creates a sense of empathy and understanding for the characters within.
Cube Escape Collection is a set of 9 point-and-click escape room-style games set within the Rusty Lake universe.
Cube Escape Collection is a set of 9 point-and-click escape room-style games set within the Rusty Lake universe. As you follow a murder case through the games, you uncover secrets and hidden meanings in unusual places that enable you to piece together what happened.
Down in Bermuda is a puzzle game where you are stranded on a set of interconnected islands.
Down in Bermuda is a puzzle game where you are stranded on a set of interconnected islands. You push, pull and manipulate objects to solve puzzles and explore the world.
Out Now: Apple TV, Mac, PC, Wii U, Xbox One and iOS
My Friendly Neighborhood is an adventure horror game where you investigate the strange set of a kid's TV show.
My Friendly Neighborhood is an adventure horror game where you investigate the strange set of a kid's TV show. Play involves traversing each of the different areas, solving puzzles and shooting the puppets that attack you.
Buddy Simulator 1984 is an adventure horror game.
Buddy Simulator 1984 is an adventure horror game. What starts as a retro-themed set of mini-games soon evolves into a tale of anxiety, friendship and depression as your buddy makes new games for you to play each with creepy anomalies and glitches.
Iron Lung is an exploration puzzle game where you navigate a submarine through a sea of blood with only your instruments to guide you.
Iron Lung is an exploration puzzle game where you navigate a submarine through a sea of blood with only your instruments to guide you. With no visibility in a small enclosed space, you need to make repairs, stop leaks and take recognisance pictures before time runs out.
Rusty Lake Hotel is a surreal point-and-click adventure with a tangential horror narrative.
Rusty Lake Hotel is a surreal point-and-click adventure with a tangential horror narrative. While set in the same universe as the other games in the Rusty Lake series, it tells its own standalone story that only shares loose connections with the other games.
Paranormasight: The Seven Mysteries of Honjo is a horror narrative game about a seemingly unconnected group of people in a suburb of Tokyo caught up in an ancient rite of resurrection.
Paranormasight: The Seven Mysteries of Honjo is a horror narrative game about a seemingly unconnected group of people in a suburb of Tokyo caught up in an ancient rite of resurrection. You search for clues and talk to characters all the while trying to enact a murder to fulfil the unique requirements of each curse to be able to resurrect someone in your own life.
Passage passage.toolness.org is a super-simple game from the same developer as One Hour One Life on the theme of a life well lived.
Passage passage.toolness.org is a super-simple game from the same developer as One Hour One Life on the theme of a life well lived. Although just a few minutes long, it offers an unusual interactive metaphor for the different stages of life that can spark deep conversations.
Out Now: Web
Reventure is a running, jumping and flying game.
Reventure is a running, jumping and flying game. Or, that's what it looks like.
Alt254 is a minimalistic adventure game.
Alt254 is a minimalistic adventure game. Using just a few pixels, it boils down the elements of adventuring (exploration, chests, enemies and landscapes) to the absolute minimum visual representation.
Landlord of the Woods is a point-and-click adventure where you play a disaffected 25-year-old who starts working as a woods keeper.
Landlord of the Woods is a point-and-click adventure where you play a disaffected 25-year-old who starts working as a woods keeper. Play involves getting the woodland houses ready for each tenant who has specific requirements.
Not Not, A Brain-Buster is a puzzle game about following simple instructions in a limited time.
Not Not, A Brain-Buster is a puzzle game about following simple instructions in a limited time. All you have to do is read the instructions and then direct your character in one of four directions.
Out Now: Android, Switch and iOS
Rusty Lake Paradise is an unusual point-and-click puzzle set in the Rusty Lake universe where you play through plagues reminiscent of the ten plagues of Egypt in the biblical story of Exodus.
Rusty Lake Paradise is an unusual point-and-click puzzle set in the Rusty Lake universe where you play through plagues reminiscent of the ten plagues of Egypt in the biblical story of Exodus. With a unique mystery at the core of the story, challenging puzzles and a story that offers connecting threads to the other games in the franchise, it's a novel entry to the series and wider fiction of Rusty Lake.
The Procession to Calvary is an intentionally peculiar point-and-click narrative told through a collage of renaissance paintings.
The Procession to Calvary is an intentionally peculiar point-and-click narrative told through a collage of renaissance paintings. You play a warrior on a quest to capture the former ruler of the land, talking to (or killing) people, interacting with objects, and solving puzzles as you go.
Out Now: Android, Mac, PC, PS4, Switch, Xbox One, Xbox X|S and iOS
10 Dead Doves is a narrative puzzle game about a hike that turns into an unnerving horror story.
10 Dead Doves is a narrative puzzle game about a hike that turns into an unnerving horror story. You move through the world, investigating items to find subtle clues and solve puzzles, all the while experiencing surreal dreamlike sequences and meeting disturbing characters.
Cracks Where the Light Gets In is a narrative game where you observe the day-to-day lives of different people and find your assumptions being subverted.
Cracks Where the Light Gets In is a narrative game where you observe the day-to-day lives of different people and find your assumptions being subverted. As you watch a refugee family from hidden viewpoints, you piece together the stories of their lives and gain a new understanding of the events that led them there.
Coming Soon: Mac and PC
If Pony Island is not age appropriate for your child, here are similar games ordered by age rating so you can find an age-appropriate alternative that’s also a game they will love.
Here are a selection of games with a similar theme to Pony Island:
These are our hand-picked alternatives to Pony Island. This doesn't use automatic matching, instead, we hand-pick games that are good to play if you have enjoyed Labyrinth. These selections also include games that offer a different experience but address a similar theme or topic.
Bananagrams is a brain game where you arrange and rearrange letters to make words.
Bananagrams is a brain game where you arrange and rearrange letters to make words. You play by taking Letter tiles from a shared pile and organising them into a crossword grid.
MicroMacro: Crime City is a puzzle brain game where you solve crimes by discovering clues hidden in black and white pictures.
MicroMacro: Crime City is a puzzle brain game where you solve crimes by discovering clues hidden in black and white pictures. You solve a series of cases that relate to different large pictures you lay out on the table between all the players.
Cantaloop is a trilogy of goofy point-and-click adventure games in book form.
Cantaloop is a trilogy of goofy point-and-click adventure games in book form. It's set in 1976 where you play Oz "Hook" Carpenter who's just returned from exile and is seeking revenge.
These are games of a similar genre mix to Pony Island. This includes games from the Puzzle, Platform, Narrative, Point-and-Click and Brain Game genres. We pick out games of a similar PEGI rating to further hone these generated suggestions.
Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective is a narrative brain game where you play a ghost that can stop time to solve crimes and save lives.
Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective is a narrative brain game where you play a ghost that can stop time to solve crimes and save lives. You can inhabit and control objects and possess corpses to alter what happens.
Out Now: DS, PC, PS4, Switch, Xbox One and iOS
Venba is a narrative cooking game where you play an Indian mother who emigrated to Canada in the 1980s.
Venba is a narrative cooking game where you play an Indian mother who emigrated to Canada in the 1980s. You cook various traditional Indian dishes and restore lost recipes which were damaged in the move to Canada.
Out Now: PC, PS5, Switch, Xbox One and Xbox X|S
Contrast is a traversal puzzle game set in a surreal 1920s world of vaudeville, film noir and jazz clubs.
Contrast is a traversal puzzle game set in a surreal 1920s world of vaudeville, film noir and jazz clubs. To move through each area you use your light to create shadowy platforms that you can use to progress.
Out Now: Android, PC, PS3, PS4, Xbox 360 and Xbox One
Alt-Frequencies is an adventure game played by listening to a series of radio shows.
Alt-Frequencies is an adventure game played by listening to a series of radio shows. It's a story about people stuck in a time loop without realising it and what you can do to save them.
Rivals is a puzzle game where you piece together the story of Josh and Luke and the breakup of their band.
Rivals is a puzzle game where you piece together the story of Josh and Luke and the breakup of their band. Playing detective, similar to Return of the Obra Dinn, but rather than murder it's musical betrayal you are sleuthing here.
Immortality is a mystery horror game where you investigate the lost movies of Marissa Marcel to unravel the mystery of her disappearance.
Immortality is a mystery horror game where you investigate the lost movies of Marissa Marcel to unravel the mystery of her disappearance. As you paw through the footage, you uncover a story that spans three decades in unnerving and horrific ways.
Out Now: Android, Mac, PC, PS5, Xbox X|S and iOS
Dear Reader is a word puzzle game.
Dear Reader is a word puzzle game. It takes classical literature and (by removing words, rearranging passages and introducing spelling errors) it tasks you with the puzzle of proofreading.
Out Now: Apple TV, Mac and iOS
Where the Heart Leads is an adventure game where you make life-choices and then see their impact.
Where the Heart Leads is an adventure game where you make life-choices and then see their impact. You play Whit Anderson, as he revisits and alters his past, present, and future.
Out Now: PS4
Who Pressed Mute on Uncle Marcus? is a murder mystery game with footage of real actors.
Who Pressed Mute on Uncle Marcus? is a murder mystery game with footage of real actors. Your family meets to play a board game on zoom, but before you start you discover someone has poisoned Uncle Marcus.
Out Now: PC, PS4 and Xbox One
Quadrilateral Cowboy is an adventure in a 1990 retro-cyberpunk world where you take on covert mission to infiltrate buildings and security systems.
Quadrilateral Cowboy is an adventure in a 1990 retro-cyberpunk world where you take on covert mission to infiltrate buildings and security systems. You carefully explore each level hacking security by typing commands into your grey-market equipment.
Desta: The Memories Between is a narrative puzzle game about returning home after leaving under difficult circumstances.
Desta: The Memories Between is a narrative puzzle game about returning home after leaving under difficult circumstances. You guide Desta through metaphorical puzzles that let you revisit painful moments of life and find the words you didn't have at the time.
Out Now: Android, PC, PS4, Switch, Xbox One and iOS
Phoenix Wright Ace Attorney is a courtroom murder mystery series where you piece together clues to challenge testimonies and uncover the truth.
Phoenix Wright Ace Attorney is a courtroom murder mystery series where you piece together clues to challenge testimonies and uncover the truth. It’s like a visual novel, although you must interact with characters and evidence to progress.
Out Now: 3DS and 2DS, Android, GBA, PC, PS4, Switch, Xbox One and iOS
In addition to the similar games listed above, which have been linked to this game specifically in the database, you may find games with a similar theme to Pony Island in the following lists: